Testing Abuse

Email us at roglucido@gmail.com

Thursday, July 30, 2009

The Extinction of Thought

A teacher wrote a math problem on the board for her class one morning. It stated, “As I was going to St. Ives, I met a man with seven wives. Every wife had seven sacks, every sack had seven cats, and every cat had seven kits. Kits, cats, sacks, and wives, how many were going to St. Ives?”

She then told the class to try and solve the problem using any means possible as individuals, and then to share their answers with each other. After a time, she asked for volunteers to share their solutions with the class. One girl came up and said, “2802, because there’s 2 men, 7 wives, 49 sacks, 343 cats, and 2401 kits.” Another boy argued vehemently against that saying, “There’s 2800 because the poem says to only count ‘kits, cats, sacks and wives’ in the last sentence.” Still, a third child raised her hand and argued yet again stating, “The answer is only 1 because it says the man was ‘on his WAY to St. Ives’. The other man and all the wives must have been coming from the other direction, so they don’t count as going to St. Ives.”

Fascinating. Just think of what goes into solving a problem like this. Multiplication, addition, subtraction, and even reading comprehension are all involved. Each student came up with a different answer, yet each one is valid in its own right because it depends on one’s point of view to justify the answer. This is critical thinking at its finest.

True critical thinking comes in the form of creative manipulation of information and divergent thinking of a problem. It is finding different ways of solving perplexing concepts. In today’s classroom, this has been exchanged for rote memorization and very low level skills. How did we get here? The federal No Child Left Behind law requires that all students take a one time, multiple choice, high stakes test each year that will determine how themselves, their school, and district have performed. There are no other ways that the law allows students to be evaluated, even though the testing companies themselves and the National Academy of Sciences dictate that there must be multiple sources of evidence used to determine student mastery of any subject area. Certainly, critical thinking problems could be explored and evaluated in an assortment of ways in reading, math, and science: oral response, projects, portfolios, presentations, etc. This is more helpful and fair to all children who show their understanding differently.

District policies often result in teaching methods that focus on narrow ways of thinking that allow only singular routes to solutions, and thus opportunities to show other valid ways are not encouraged. In computer scientist and artificial intelligence researcher Marvin Minsky’s book, The Society of Mind, he states, “If you understand something in only one way, then you really do not understand it at all. This is because if something goes wrong you get stuck with a thought that just sits in your mind with nowhere to go.” This is what is happening to our kids. Over twelve long years they are being trapped into a mindless prison.

Now Education Secretary Arne Duncan wants to tie test scores to teacher performance and even have a national test linked to national standards. Just think of what this will do. Our children will now be forced to all look the ‘same’ and will be stuffed into a pressure cooker of test, test, test, score, score, and score to justify a teacher’s salary! What happened to the children’s learning and individualism? This is the reduction of human intellect on steroids. There has never been research that shows that more testing equals more learning. Parents should be outraged.

Minsky states that, “The secret of what anything means to us depends on how we have connected it to all the other things that we know. If you have several different representations, when one approach fails, you can try another.” What has made this country great has been our creativity and outside of the box thinking. The basic principle of unique thought will become extinct with our current educational policy. Think about it and say no.


  • At 11:49 PM, Anonymous Marvin Minsky said…

    Wow, yes. Let's all say NO to the extension of what should be renamed to: "All Children Left Behind."

    -- Minsky

  • At 4:40 PM, Blogger EPATA Educators and Parents Against Testing Abuse said…

    Wow! It's really neat to see the author I quoted support my piece. Thanks for your wisdom, Mr. Minsky.



  • At 8:34 PM, Blogger minsky said…

    Thanks. I recently wrote several essays about negative aspects of present-day education. See

    (and change "1" to 2,3,4,5 for the other ones).

    But I missed many problems that you've pointed out, that would come from tethering teachers' pay to test-based ratings. Instead of getting our kids to hunger for knowledge, this would only teach them to fear it.

  • At 8:49 AM, Blogger EPATA Educators and Parents Against Testing Abuse said…

    I agree, And now I'm working on another piece that challenges linking scores to teacher pay because it, in my opinion, would constitute child labor. I've started to do research on that, but I think I can make a very compelling case for it.


  • At 11:09 PM, Anonymous learn quran said…

    wow, Nice information!Thanks for sharing.

  • At 6:17 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I found this site using [url=http://google.com]google.com[/url] And i want to thank you for your work. You have done really very good site. Great work, great site! Thank you!

    Sorry for offtopic

  • At 8:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
    Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!

  • At 4:32 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    midlands dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]adult dating liverpool[/url] naked pics personals http://loveepicentre.com/ american chinese free dating site

  • At 2:45 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    how do i apply to masshealth as a mental health provider [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/catalogue/y.htm]medications without a prescription[/url] is ther a disease called irish depression syndrome http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/vasotec.htm child anxiety scale http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/trental.htm
    heart palpitations b deficiency [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/ponstel.htm]ponstel[/url] white curd like vaginal discharge [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/plavix.htm]pharmacy technician jobs in delaware[/url]

  • At 3:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    beaded puffed heart pattern [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/smettere-di-fumare.htm]smettere di fumare[/url] compartment syndrome thigh http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/depakote.htm speciality health reno http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/miglioramento-femminile.htm
    korallin 1502 calcium reactor [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/calcium-carbonate.htm]calcium carbonate[/url] marin county breast enlargement [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/astelin.htm]cheap weight loss spas[/url]

  • At 2:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    advance stages of pickwegan syndrome [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/arthritis.htm]arthritis[/url] affiliate health program shopping http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/anti-pilz.htm henry schein sports medicine http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/lozol.htm
    experience with mammogram and breast implants [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/mevacor.htm]mevacor[/url] rush university medical [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/disclaimer.htm]health and reabilitation of englewood florida[/url]

  • At 6:55 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=http://online-health.in/augmentin/augmentin-sr]sex and drugs computer game[/url] lake superior drug and gang task force [url=http://online-health.in/bacteria]bacteria[/url]
    edex injections for erectile disfunction http://online-health.in/arimidex/arimidex-and-weight-gain
    [url=http://online-health.in/baclofen/baclofen-information]compare cialis levitra viagra[/url] testing 5 drug enthanol blood [url=http://online-health.in/antidiabetic/moringa-leaf-extracts-as-an-antidiabetic]moringa leaf extracts as an antidiabetic[/url]
    bush senior drug program contribute medicare http://online-health.in/biaxin/biaxin-xl-stomach-pain
    [url=http://online-health.in/antibiotic/antibiotic-resistance-university-of-illinois]what drugs are classified as cll[/url] drugs mesclin [url=http://online-health.in/aspirin/can-i-take-aspirin-with-ibuprofen-htm]can i take aspirin with ibuprofen htm[/url] cost of pharmacy counseling [url=http://online-health.in/atacand/side-effects-of-atacand]side effects of atacand[/url]

  • At 10:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=http://poow.in/mefenamic/mefenamic]soviet drugs[/url] pharmacy technician certification online [url=http://poow.in/lamotrigine/lamotrigine-and-bipolar-monotherapy]lamotrigine and bipolar monotherapy[/url]
    pharmacy complaints http://poow.in/metformin/metformin-and-pain-reliever-interactions
    [url=http://poow.in/medrol/xanthoma-depo-medrol]generic drugs and name brands[/url] medicare coverage drug narcotic panel [url=http://poow.in/mestinon/usual-dose-of-mestinon-for-myasthenia]usual dose of mestinon for myasthenia[/url]
    y do peeps do drugs http://poow.in/gaba/gaba-and-insomnia
    [url=http://poow.in/risedronate/risedronate-sodium-tablets]cheapest cialis online[/url] radio discussion of ben cousins drug addiction [url=http://poow.in/rimonabant/where-can-i-buy-rimonabant]where can i buy rimonabant[/url] buy cialis on line [url=http://poow.in/gemfibrozil]gemfibrozil[/url]

  • At 12:26 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    phuket travel timeshare http://livetravel.in/cruise/cruise-stops-port-canaveral travel network maui
    [url=http://livetravel.in/hotel/linchris-hotel-corporation]travel times for car[/url] travel trac i force inertial trainer reviews [url=http://livetravel.in/airlines/interlink-airlines]interlink airlines[/url]
    joint custody with the right to travel http://livetravel.in/tour/eagles-1977-tour-dates
    [url=http://livetravel.in/expedia/hotel-motel-orlando-florida-airport-expedia]travel services international[/url] hrd time travel [url=http://livetravel.in/adventure/adventure-science-museum-brentwood-tn]adventure science museum brentwood tn[/url]
    new castle pa travel agencies http://livetravel.in/tours/western-grand-canyon-tours
    [url=http://livetravel.in/plane-tickets/budget-plane-tickets]health insurance international student travel check[/url] life travel magazine [url=http://livetravel.in/flight/lufthansa-flight-information-toronto]lufthansa flight information toronto[/url] travel questions ireland [url=http://livetravel.in/cruise/a994-audi-s4-cruise-control-problems]a994 audi s4 cruise control problems[/url]
    travel trailers with no carpet [url=http://livetravel.in/airport/airlines-at-st-thomas-airport]airlines at st thomas airport[/url]
    kayak travel site itineraries http://livetravel.in/cruises/mentally-challenged-cruises
    [url=http://livetravel.in/tours/home-showcases-tours]pitts travel agency[/url] personnel security travel [url=http://livetravel.in/lufthansa/boeing-737-800-delta]boeing 737 800 delta[/url]
    [url=http://livetravel.in/tour/seseme-street-studio-tour]seseme street studio tour[/url] shanghai travel cheap [url=http://livetravel.in/airport/van-taxi-from-embassy-suites-miami-airport-to-cruise-ship]van taxi from embassy suites miami airport to cruise ship[/url] flagstaff rv travel trailer [url=http://livetravel.in/tour/north-italian-lakes-tour]north italian lakes tour[/url]
    travel trailer porch slides [url=http://livetravel.in/tour/international-tour-companies-based-in-us]international tour companies based in us[/url]

  • At 12:31 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    travel on travel on http://adventurecollection.in/tours/boston-fall-foliage-day-tours australian fiji discount air travel
    [url=http://adventurecollection.in/airline/sw-airline-htm]travel today[/url] global travel clock [url=http://adventurecollection.in/cruises/cruises-out-of-mobile]cruises out of mobile[/url]
    travel weekly us http://adventurecollection.in/inn/shiretown-inn-houlton-maine
    [url=http://adventurecollection.in/cruises/ferry-cruises-east-coast]travel direction for newcastle[/url] vagabon travel alaska [url=http://adventurecollection.in/vacation-packages/group-vacation-package-and-las-vegas]group vacation package and las vegas[/url]
    lg cu500 travel charger http://adventurecollection.in/tours/cypress-valley-canopy-tours famil vaction and travel ideas [url=http://adventurecollection.in/vacation-packages/best-deal-on-vacation-package-for-south-padre-island]best deal on vacation package for south padre island[/url]

  • At 4:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    adult sound clip http://xwe.in/girl-anal/women-and-anal-sex
    [url=http://xwe.in/thong/cadid-thong-video]adult shoe store encounters[/url] adult to do lists [url=http://xwe.in/shemale/shemale-lesbians-cumshot]shemale lesbians cumshot[/url]
    monster dildo sex http://xwe.in/girl-anal/anal-sex-feels-like
    [url=http://xwe.in/gay-anal/gay-wedding-locations]erotic adult vacations buenos aires[/url] gay punk rock porn [url=http://xwe.in/gay-anal]gay anal[/url]
    best adult personals for cincinnati http://xwe.in/oral/nipples-sore-while-on-oral-contraceptives
    [url=http://xwe.in/archive-adult/upcoming-adult-movies]virgin megastore ireland[/url] free anime hentai movies [url=http://xwe.in/orgy/roman-orgy-pics]roman orgy pics[/url]
    adult toy catalogue http://xwe.in/orgasm/leticia-cline-orgasm-video
    [url=http://xwe.in/teen-ass/a-dumb-ass-from-olney-texas]anal lingus[/url] hentai game web site [url=http://xwe.in/bdsm/female-chastity-bdsm-galleries]female chastity bdsm galleries[/url]

  • At 12:41 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    winter fashion on the street http://www.thefashionhouse.us/black-red-roberto-cavalli-color15.html toddler boys shoes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/turquoise-casual-tops-color85.html]lebanese fashion clothing[/url] pics of women removing shoes
    http://www.thefashionhouse.us/polo-shirts-page2.html bedding and ralph lauren [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/black-white-women-s-tops-color187.html]a fashion legacy rico puhlmann[/url]

  • At 4:29 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    fashion illustrators http://luxefashion.us/shoes-page14.html orthopedic shoes [url=http://luxefashion.us/killah-women-brand24.html]fanco s shoes[/url] girls fashion sneakers
    http://luxefashion.us/napapijri-casual-shirts-brand62.html pentagon fashion center [url=http://luxefashion.us/napapijri-polo-shirt-for-women-sky-blue-item2207.html]russian ballet shoes[/url]

  • At 9:55 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    atlas snowshoes http://www.thefashionhouse.us/grey-casual-shirts-color1.html information on iversonsnowshoes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/outwear-page2.html]lauren zamerilla[/url] childrens high heelde shoes
    http://www.thefashionhouse.us/-classic-denim-men-category15.html fashion photographer portland [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/navy-blue-dark-grey-men-color236.html]clothes color match[/url]

  • At 1:26 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    deals red travel http://xwl.in/vacation-packages/find-cheap-vacation-packages-to-santa-fe-new-mexico sos travel insurance
    [url=http://xwl.in/inn]isic travel cuts[/url] travel plug for powerbook [url=http://xwl.in/travel/aircraft-travel-pods]aircraft travel pods[/url]
    travel supreme 06 insignia specifications http://xwl.in/disneyland/paradise-pier-hotel-disneyland
    [url=http://xwl.in/inn/redlion-inn]ok travel agency[/url] usah travel bag [url=http://xwl.in/car-rental/cheap-car-rental-manchester]cheap car rental manchester[/url]
    gps travel http://xwl.in/expedia/expedia-web travel package las vegas [url=http://xwl.in/airline/american-airline-arena]american airline arena[/url]

  • At 3:40 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    fun spin casino guide http://xwn.in/gambling-online_gambling-facts-australia super jackpot party slot machine
    [url=http://xwn.in/slot_magma-2-slot]pima county jackpot saila show[/url] free florida lottery [url=http://xwn.in/roulette_winning-online-roulette]winning online roulette[/url]
    fake lottery ticets http://xwn.in/poker-online_top-online-casino-games-poker-htm
    [url=http://xwn.in/online-casino_sams-town-casino-tunica]common lottery winning numbers[/url] printing bingo cards [url=http://xwn.in/lottery_canadian-cancer-lottery]canadian cancer lottery[/url]
    milton bradley bingo game http://xwn.in/blackjack_blackjack-26-catamaran-battery-life harrahs casino loughlin nevada [url=http://xwn.in/poker-online_real-clay-poker-chips]real clay poker chips[/url]

  • At 10:25 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    total earnings transformers movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_joe_versus_the_volcano/]joe versus the volcano[/url] movie times for boardman ohio http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_christmas_caper/ fantasy island and movie
    hairspray movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_after_the_sunset/]after the sunset[/url] movie and the mob http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_antitrust/ transformers the movie pics
    download p2 movie trailer [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_10_things_i_hate_about_you/]10 things i hate about you[/url] ago day world evil homer top yahoo chart movie film
    cineplex movie theatre in ontario [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_run_silent_run_deep/]run silent run deep[/url] free movie wallpapers http://moviestrawberry.com/hqmoviesbycountry/country_usa/?page=12 movie silver spring md
    conflict of movie apocalypto [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_lost_mission/]lost mission[/url] underdog movie 48114 http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_hated/ movie forums


Post a Comment

<< Home